A typical example of multiple element arrangement is provision by a company of hardware and customised software, with installation, training and maintenance services, and the option to receive free updates, all negotiated together with a single customer. Revenues from contracts with multiple element arrangements, such as those including. Accounting for bundled services multielement arrangements. Revenue recognition under multi element arrangements by kevin lalor jul 3, 20 as we mentioned in yesterdays post, software companies tend to bundle together software licenses fees, installation and maintenance services, training, upgrade rights, and professional services into a multi element product offering. Asc 60525 provides guidance on the separability of deliverables included in an arrangement into different units of accounting and the allocation of an arrangement s consideration to those units of accounting. Revenue recognition for saas and software companies. When accounting for multiple element arrangements, gaap indicates that sellers can separately record revenue for part of an arrangement even if the part does not have value to the customer on a standalone basis. If an undelivered element relates to a deliverable within the scope of. May 07, 2007 multi element arrangement occurs when a vendor agrees to provide more than one product or a combination of products and services to a customer in an arrangement. Under the new sop if an arrangement to deliver software does not require significant production, modification, or customization of the software, then the new sop specifies four criteria which must be met prior to recognizing revenue from a single element arrangement or for individual elements in a multiple element arrangement. This multiple element approach involves the following primary steps. As a result, software products that are essential to the function of any nonsoftware products will also be included under the scope of sop 972. As a computer software company, jda s ability to recognize revenue from the sale of software and related services in a multiple element arrangement was governed broadly by asc 985 605. New gaap for multiple deliverables journal of accountancy.
Vsoe is critical because if a company cannot assert that it possesses vsoe for each element in a multipleelement arrangement particularly those products or services still to be delivered, the likely result is deferral of some, if not all, of the arrangements associated revenue. Asc 605 provides industryspecific guidance for entities in the software industry, entities that enter into constructiontype or productiontype contracts, and entities in the entertainment and financial services industries, among others. Revenue on multiple element arrangements is recognized using the residual method of revenue recognition when companyspecific objective evidence of fair value exists for all of the undelivered elements for example, support services, consulting, or other services in the arrangement, but does not exist for one or more delivered elements. Fasb asu 2009, multipledeliverable revenue arrangements, changes the accounting. These practice issues, if not appropriately addressed, could have significant consequences on a vendors financial statements, including a misstatement of the vendors revenue for the period. These rules prescribe when elements within a multiple element, or bundled, software arrangement can be accounted for as separate accounting units. A simplified common multiple element arrangement at my company is. Measurement and allocation requirements the arrangement consideration must be. Revenues from contracts with multiple element arrangements are recognized as each element is earned based on the relative fair value of each element provided the delivered elements have value to customers on a standalone basis.
We can allocate the value to each element in several ways. Revenue recognition topic 605 an amendment of the fasb accounting standards codificationtm no. These elements to which revenue amounts are assigned by gaap are referred to as separate units of accounting. The attached publication, multipleelement arrangementsa roadmap to applying the. In order t o recognize the full amount of revenue from the sale of a software license. Fair value of services within an arrangement 91 661. The attached publication, multipleelement arrangements a roadmap to applying the revenue recognition guidance in asu 2009, which is the latest addition to deloittes roadmap series, summarizes the changes made by asu 2009 and provides interpretive guidance on applying its provisions. Under gaap, with respect to multiple element arrangements, if the revenue for a particular part of a multiple part arrangement does not qualify for separate recognition, it is. Revenue recognition under multielement arrangements bi101. Example of determining the applicability of sop 811 to a software arrangement 92 721. This type of transaction frequently occurs for technology firms that sell a variety of services e. In order to adequately recognize revenue over the duration of a contract, it is important to identify each individual deliverable in a given contract. Multi element arrangement occurs when a vendor agrees to provide more than one product or a combination of products and services to a customer in an arrangement.
Asc 60525 provides guidance on the separability of deliverables included in an arrangement into different units of accounting and the allocation of an arrangements consideration to those units of accounting. Revenue recognition for software products with multiple. According to the sop, there are different accounting rules applicable when elements are considered a software element or a service element. The impact of the new revenue recognition guidance on. Multipleelement arrangements a roadmap to applying the. At present, there are special accounting rules for companies that sell bundled software andor software related deliverables. Revenue recognition under multielement arrangements. Fair value standalone selling price in multipleelement. The attached publication, multipleelement arrangementsa roadmap to applying the revenue recognition guidance in asu 2009, which is the latest addition to deloittes roadmap series, summarizes the changes made by asu 2009 and provides interpretive guidance on applying its provisions.
New revenue guidance implementation in the software industry. Recognized when revenue for the other parts is recognized. In most situations, the new guidance will result in earlier revenue recognition for financial reporting purposes. Revenue is recognized when it is realized or realizable and earned. The new revenue standards asc 606 and ifrs 15, revenue from contracts with customers replace industryspecific. Separately priced services in a software arrangement 91 691. Sop 972 provides the necessary guidance when dealing with multipleelement arrangements. Revenue recognition software sop 972 wittsiepe consulting. Accounting for bundled services multielement arrangements for. This video shows how to recognize revenue for bundled services in a multi element arrangement. The delivered item has value to the customer on a standalone basis. New guidelines for software revenue recognition practical. In multiple element arrangements involving software and consulting, training, or other professional services that are not essential to the functionality of the software, the service revenues are accounted for separately from the software revenues.
Revenue recognition within the software industry has historically been highly complex with much industryspecific guidance. Revenue arrangements with multiple deliverables bpm accounting. When accounting for multiple element software arrangements, the revenue for each element is based on the separate prices stated for each element in. In connection with accessing and using software products, an arrangement in which the customer of the software does not currently have possession of the software. Since it was issued and effective for new multiple element arrangements beginning in fiscal periods. We have prepared accounting for multipledeliverable revenue arrangements to be used as a firstline resource in addressing some of these practice issues. Multiple element arrangement how is multiple element.
Cloud computing arrangements often contain multiple deliverables, such as activation or setup fees, a software license, a hosting service, future upgrades, technical support, and customization costs. Everything you need to know about vsoe but are afraid to ask paul lamparski finance director, global revenues. Revenue recognition multipleelement arrangements deloitte us. Multipleelement arrangements additional software deliverables and rights to exchange or. Jan 17, 2016 this video shows how to recognize revenue for bundled services in a multi element arrangement. However, it does not address when revenue should be recognized. Accounting for multipledeliverable revenue arrangements. Multi element arrangements may include additional software products, rights to purchase additional software products at a significant incremental discount, specified upgrades or. Multiple deliverable products that include software incidental to the products or services as a whole will be guided by emerging issues task force eitf issue 0021. For software companies and companies that have not adopted eitf 081, the value is. New eitf revenue recognition standards for multiple. Jun 05, 2007 if a multiple element software arrangement includes explicit or implicit rights to pcs, pcs is a separate element of the arrangement. Software revenue recognition on the rise journal of accountancy. Define elements defining each element of the software arrangement i.
If a general return right exists for the delivered item, delivery or. We have prepared accounting for multiple deliverable revenue arrangements to be used as a firstline resource in addressing some of these practice issues. We hope that financial statement preparers will find this roadmap helpful. Therefore, all revenue under those arrangements was recognized ratably over the related service period. The second fundamental change in standards due to asu 2009 is the approach to the allocation of revenue to the various elements of a multiple element arrangement. Multiple deliverable arrangements february 06, 2015 revenue recognition is an increasingly important topic for private companies operating in the technology and life sciences sector. Since we frequently sell both training and consulting services separately, we have met the standalone value criteria. Multi element arrangement aka occurs when a vendor agrees to provide more than one product or a combination of products and services to a customer in an arrangement. A comprehensive guide revenue recognition multiple element. We have evaluated the deliverables in our multiple element arrangements and concluded that they are separate units of accounting if the delivered item or items have value to the customer on a standalone basis and for an arrangement that includes a general right of return relative to the delivered items, delivery or performance of the.
710 114 1228 1301 1372 1507 742 1653 1077 1148 547 629 562 228 1460 86 1094 489 103 1454 638 140 659 660 67 417 258 1033 1008 1300 1193 678 1216 1328 106 1412 107 97 663